If one of the creatures is an illegal target and the other one isn't as The Earth Crystal's last ability tries to resolve, the original distribution of counters applies and the counter that would have been put on the illegal target is lost
In a deck that's 40% creatures, I should have a lot of hits
A quick ebay search shows one for $1400 buy it now and thats without checking sold comparisons if thats what they normally go for
becomes a game-ending problem
Lillies Clefairy ex SAR leads at 28,000 (~$190), and the first-print Ns Zoroark ex UR error trades above 250,000
And remember, while our service is not officially endorsed by Wizards of the Coast, we are committed to maintaining the spirit and fun of Magic: The Gathering in everything we do