Removing a shield counter when a permanent would be dealt damage or destroyed isn't the same as regenerating a creature
Plus, reasonably costed 5/5s dont need much more to be commander viable, while pirates look like theyll be falling in the 2/2 to 4/3 range, which need much more help to make them work
Its popularity isnt undeserved, either
They allow you to bring out any nonland permanent from your graveyard with haste whenever a historic spell is cast
Like most Magic: The Gathering cards, the value of Long Goodbye depends on a few consistent factors: its rarity, the printing and finish (regular or foil), its physical condition, and the set it was printed in (Murders at Karlov Manor)
P/T Number 96 Language English Legal Formats Commander, Legacy, Vintage Not Legal Formats Alchemy, Brawl, Competitive Brawl, Historic, Modern, Pauper, Pioneer, Standard, Timeless Rulings (10/7/2022) Old One-Eye's Fast Healing ability only triggers if it is in your graveyard at the beginning of your precombat main phase
